Is the Fourth Cup BY Scott Hahn Too Neat and Tidy

I actually agree somewhat with the good Jesuit from NOLA on this a tad. The Fourth Cup all seemed a tad new neat and tidy to me also so I an not still too sure about it. Though let me clear I am a big fan of Scott Hahn , Pitre , and others like him and their work. So I am not endorsing the criticism by the the other Priest he links as to a earlier article. See Brant Pitre, Benedict XVI, And Why The Pope Has It Right